In the US anyway – it’s such a hot debate at the moment – should mommies drink or not while on a “playdate”. I mean, honestly, I’m sure it hasn’t even occurred to French women that this could in fact be a real dilemma.
But I can seen where the debate is coming from. We as mommies are being told at every opportunity how we f*** up our children – firstly it was considered bad form to go back to work, now it’s considered bad form to stay at home. How long you breastfeed for has always been a hot topic; breastfeed not long enough and your children will be obese, stupid and not attached – breastfeed for too long and your children will be skinny clingers with no sense of self-esteem. And please, don’t even dream of breastfeeding in public.
Maybe I should be grateful that my French, German or Italian isn’t good enough to understand what their hot issues are, but it seems to me that the Americans and British are especially good at dishing out admonishments and warnings.
The drinking issue is a case in point.
I first became aware of the concept with the publication of Christie Mellor’s book, The Three-Martini Playdate, A practical guide to Happy Parenting. She makes the point that parents were there first and children should fit in with the existing family structure and not become little gods that run our lives, which I wholeheartedly support.
So, things were simmering away quietly until a while ago, when the Today show decided to run a segment on mommies who *gasp* drink in front of their children, and everybody with an opinion jumped on the bandwagon. But, to put it in context for all of us, just remember that this is the country that came up with prohibition, and a fat lot of good it did them too.
It did lead to some very entertaining blogs written, for instance, Izzymom came to the conclusion that there are a lot of people out there who think that mothers lose their ability to make a sane decision the minute they give birth.
Some other interesting blogs worth checking out is:
Melissa Summers who started the whole debate at Suburban Bliss and Buzz Off, two really really funny blogging sites and worth subscribing to. She invented the term Momtini – which is according to the Global Language Monitor the 9th most politically incorrect phrase of 2006 – Quote: “Momtini — A Michigan mother invented the term ‘momtini’ as an act of rebellion against ‘parental correctness’. This has raised the hackles of child protection and ‘anti-alcohol’ groups.”
There is a great piece in the NY Times on the subject, worth reading (man, I DO love that newspaper), which pretty much sums up where I stand on the subject. An interesting point that does come up in the article, is that moms who have the occassional drinking playdates, are much less judgemental over other parents and their children – I like that.
At least I know now that I hang out with the right kind of people – it never occurred to us that you could HAVE a playdate without wine.
Personally, I find that certain things just go so much better with alcohol, like a bunch of screaming 2-year olds and their assortment of smaller siblings.